Better Sealed Than Sorry

Choosing budgets over bulk systems should consider this one problem area

Better Sealed Than Sorry

Once upon a time, there was nothing but bulk. Whether we were talking about public toilets or office restrooms, schools or hospitals, soap dispensers holding their products in a refillable reservoir were the only alternative to a bar of soap or lotion from a bottle.

This was for good reason: Bulk dispensers left far less mess than bar soaps and were inexpensive. However, budget-driven decisions in favor of bulk systems did not always take one issue into consideration that we now recognize as extremely problematic—bacterial contamination.

Contamination in Bulk Dispensers

Bulk systems are not sealed, leaving the exposed soap vulnerable to contamination from the environment or from the hands of the person refilling and handling the dispenser system. The widely applied practice of “topping-off” dispensers—refilling them before they are completely empty and have been cleaned properly—means the old soap in the reservoir may already be exposed to germs, resulting in contamination of new soap. Even if your staff frequently cleans the equipment with aggressive products there is still a high risk of recontamination due to microorganisms that stick to each other and adhere to surfaces, according to a 2012 study analysis, “Evaluation and Remediation of Bulk Soap Dispensers for Biofilm.

A Safe Alternative

Sealed dispenser systems offer a safe alternative to bulk dispensers. Here’s why:

  1. They mitigate contamination. Sealed dispensers eliminate contact between the product and the environment, creating a closed system, and can be refilled by inserting a sealed cartridge of soap into the dispenser. This method reduces risk of contamination.
  2. They can help with efficiencies. In contrast to the often messy refilling procedure of bulk dispensers, sealed cartridges are quick and easy to change. Spills are no longer an issue, and sealed cartridge dispensers require minimal cleaning. Maintenance is also extremely low, saving time, and in turn, money.
  3. They can prevent product waste. Some cartridge dispensers are designed to deliver exactly the right amount of a specific product at any given time—whereas bulk dispensers tend to deliver the same quantity no matter the product they are filled with.

Increase Compliance

An easy-to-use, sealed cartridge dispenser system can make a significant contribution to increasing hand hygiene compliance. Restroom users are much more likely to wash their hands with soap if the product is available from a pleasant-looking, clean, and tidy dispensing system.

Additionally, sealed cartridge dispensers are safer and more hygienic than their bulk counterparts; they minimize the risk of bacterial contamination and help to prevent infections; they save companies time and money; and they ease the burden on the environment. If you consider all of these advantages together, it really is better to be sealed than sorry.

Posted On August 31, 2017

Isabelle Faivre

Vice president of marketing at Deb Group

Isabelle Faivre is vice president of marketing at Deb Group, the world’s leading away-from-home skin care company. She holds extensive away-from-home market experience and a bachelor of science in international marketing from McGill University and ESSCA. Faivre works with customers to provide innovative skin care programs that improve employee health and safety and environmental impact while reducing costs. Deb’s most recent innovations include Solopol® GFX, the world’s only heavy-duty foam hand cleaner and Deb InstantFOAM® Complete, an innovative hand sanitizing solution for bacteria, viruses, fungi and yeast. For more information, visit

Topics Tags

Also in Infection Control

June 30, 2020 Craig Sykora

How to Prevent Cross-Contamination

June 23, 2020 Eric Bates

Using UV Systems to Combat HAIs

June 12, 2020 Michael Catanzaro

Infection Prevention: EVS Leads the Way With Interdisciplinary Teamwork

June 9, 2020 Peter Teska

Perfecting the Electrostatic Cleaning Process

Sponsored in Infection Control

ElectroChemically Activated Cleaning and Disinfecting Solutions
April 6, 2017 Sponsored by PathoSans

ElectroChemically Activated Cleaning and Disinfecting Solutions

December 1, 2016 Sponsored by PathoSans

PathoSans® PS30 ElectroChemically Activated Solution System

September 1, 2016 Sponsored by Kutol Products Co.

Multi-color Kids Dispensers and Kid-friendly Soaps

September 1, 2016 Sponsored by PathoSans

PathoSans® PS30 ElectroChemically Activated Solution System

Recent News

Weekly Advocacy Recap—Job Gains and PPP Loan Extension
July 6, 2020 CMM Daily News

Weekly Advocacy Recap—Job Gains and PPP Loan Extension

July 6, 2020 CMM Daily News

Perceptions Influence Cleaning Results

July 6, 2020 CMM Daily News

Hotel Investigation Raises Doubts About Enhanced Cleaning Protocols

July 2, 2020 CMM Daily News

Meet the CMM Hard Floor Care Webinar Speakers

Better Sealed Than Sorry
Share Article
Subscribe to CMM